Ep. 18 How to Stop Playing Small & Start Showing Up Bold
Break Free from Self-Doubt and Step into Your Full Potential
In this episode of the ProblemSolvHer Podcast, Chloe and Dagmar unpack the subtle (and major) ways we play small in life — and how to shift out of it. From shrinking in social situations to skipping dream opportunities, you’ll learn what it takes to stop holding back and start showing up fully.
Watch this ProblemSolvHer Podcast Video
Watch the ProblemSolvHer Podcast Episode Video on YouTube.
Table of Contents
Topics Covered in This Episode:
- What Does It Mean to Play Small?
Understanding the subtle ways we shrink ourselves in personal and professional settings and how it holds us back. - Breaking Free from Fear and Limiting Beliefs
How to identify the fears that keep you stuck and the mindset shifts necessary to step into your full potential. - The Importance of Showing Up Fully
Why it’s crucial to be unapologetically you in every situation and how it impacts your life, relationships, and success. - Practical Tips for Overcoming Self-Doubt
Simple strategies to stop shrinking and start showing up as your authentic, bold self. - How Playing Small Affects Your Happiness and Success
The hidden costs of holding back and how it limits your growth, both personally and professionally. - Real-Life Stories of Playing Small and How to Shift It
Personal anecdotes from Chloe and Dagmar about moments when they played small and how they turned it around.
Timestamps & Chapters
00:00 – Welcome to ProblemSolvHer
01:13 – What does “playing small” mean?
02:46 – Playing small in career & relationships
04:12 – How fear holds us back
06:56 – Chloe’s regret: skipping her Harper’s Bazaar interview
09:35 – Dagmar’s experience with people-pleasing
10:43 – Speaking up without taking over
12:42 – How Chloe handled a sports convo with bold facts
15:49 – Delivering the truth with confidence
16:58 – Facts vs. feelings online & offline
17:57 – Takeaway: how to stop playing small
19:15 – Chloe’s advice: Believe in yourself
21:09 – Why this work matters
22:01 – Subscribe & stay connected
Tools & Takeaways
Spot the Subtle Shrinking
From holding back your opinions to turning down opportunities, playing small doesn’t always look dramatic—but it always costs you.
📝 Self-check: Are you staying quiet to keep the peace or because you’re scared of being seen?
Chloe: “I skipped the Harper’s Bazaar interview—and I still think about it 20 years later.”
The Missed Shot
Whether it’s in love, career, or even sports (hello, college tennis!), not going all in can leave a lasting sting.
Ask yourself: Where have I been playing not to lose instead of playing to win?
Insight: Regret often comes not from failure, but from not even trying.
The Nice Girl Trap
When you’re raised to be pleasing and polite, you learn to minimize your presence—on purpose.
Dagmar: “I knew the answer, but I held back just to fit in.”
Tip: Fitting in is not the same as belonging.
Speak with Substance, Not Ego
You don’t have to dominate a conversation to add value.
Example script: “I actually have some experience with this topic. Mind if I share another perspective?”
Deliver facts calmly. Let your credibility speak louder than your volume.
Emotional Cleanse for Bigger Moves
Playing small is rooted in fear—and fear needs an exit route.
Chloe: “Chuck the fear into the ocean. All of it. Don’t even let it sit in your body.”
Tip: Write down what you’re afraid of—then reframe it. Instead of “I might fail,” try “I’ll learn faster than most.”
Expansion Requires Intentional Action
Dagmar: “You can’t play big if you’re still living from your childhood patterns.
Break the loop:
- Identify where you’re shrinking
- Visualize your bold self
- Act from her today, not someday
Coaching Cue
Tired of dimming your light to stay safe?
Chloe’s coaching is here to help you build confidence, clarity, and bold momentum.
Book a session: problemsolvher.com/coaching-for-women-ready-to-own-their-voice
Full Podcast Transcript:
Read the full conversation from this episode of the ProblemSolvHer Podcast.
Perfect if you prefer to skim, revisit your favorite moments, or take notes while you listen.
Introduction: Welcome to the ProblemSolvHer Podcast
Chloe (00:05): Hello everyone and welcome to the Problem Solver Podcast where women of all ages come together, and men, and give us their fabulous insights and their really cool advice. And I’m your host, Chloe, along with my girl.
Dagmar (00:25): Thank you.
Chloe (00:26): Dagmar’s in the house. God bless Dagmar because this week I’ve kind of been lagging everybody. I had a really big trip and then I never got jet lagged but I’m just tired overall. And Dagmar comes in with like the sunshine and the rainbows and a smile. And she helps bring out my energy. It’s like I just drank a Red Bull looking at her. So Dagmar.
Dagmar (00:51): It’s a happy day.
What Does It Mean to Play Small?
Chloe (00:53): t’s a happy day. Listen, every day
Dagmar (00:54): It’s a happy day.
Chloe (00:55): to be alive is a happy day. Let’s start there, right? Give thanks for life.
Dagmar (00:59): Yes. And that’s a great starter because topic today is does it mean to play small, So let’s talk first about What does it mean to play small?
Chloe (01:13): Well, a lot of people might not even know what that term means, right? Playing small. So my interpretation of what playing small is, is not taking risks, right? Everything you do is like, no, it’s right in the box, right? It’s not, I’m not taking any risks, I’m being very calculated. And so it’s like the famous saying, think big, right?
So if you’re playing small, you’re doing something that you know isn’t gonna really challenge you and you’re kind of staying in a job where you’re like, all right, it’s paying the bills, putting food on the table. It’s paying for my, you know, my nice manicures on the weekends and going out to dinners, but it’s not a challenge. So it’s kind of like giving yourself that small role.
Playing Small in Relationships and Family
And the same in personal relationships and with family. Not, know, if there’s something that’s bothering you with someone that you’re very close with or a family member and you’re like, don’t want to go there. I’m just going to keep it light. No, extrapolate, tell people. What I think is the worst is to be passive aggressive. And what I mean by that is someone who kind of, it’s almost like being a people pleaser, right? In the sense where that’s how you grew up and, not that you know you’re being one, but kind of, yes, okay, great, sounds good. And then all of a sudden, explosion goes off. So let’s start, think big people. Think big or go home.
Dagmar (02:46): Another way to play small is also not to show your expertise and your knowledge to hold back. You hold back because you’re scared of being seen and heard because then you could be judged.
The Fear of Judgment: Downplaying Yourself
Chloe (02:54): downplaying yourself. Yeah. Listen, we’re all judged no matter what. I hate to say it. And I think it’s human nature. When somebody walks into a room and you’ve never met them before, the first five minutes of that conversation is most likely going to determine if you’re going to have a friendship with that person or if it’s personal, I will judge in 32 seconds and just size somebody up or down and then go yes or no. But think of it as you’re at a party and you know most of the people and someone walks in that you don’t know. And for whatever reason you’re intimidated by that person, you’re gonna judge them immediately. If they don’t intimidate you, you’re gonna go up to them right away and start a conversation. Unfortunately, it’s of, it’s think of the animal kingdom. It’s the same thing. I mean, that’s, you know, we’re all from the wild originally.
Breaking Free from Fear: Overcoming the Barrier of Playing Small
Dagmar (03:52): you cannot go big, not because you don’t want to, but don’t have plan or the structure or the insights or the awareness to switch it. can somebody stop playing small if they recognize that and don’t want to do it anymore?
Chloe (04:12): Well, you just sort of fear and I’ve animals, especially cats and dogs, because they’re so close to humans. They react as humans do. And I think fear has a big place in that. And if you’re constantly fearful and you’re constantly on the hamster wheel about what you don’t want, I don’t want this, I don’t want that, I don’t want this, I don’t want that, want to do this. Instead of, you know, throwing the tape out the window.
I’m saying cassette tape, okay? People don’t even listen to DVDs anymore. Before you record your Spotify, there’s your plug, Spotify. Thank you for having us on Spotify podcast and Apple podcast and YouTube. Is that the same thing keeps happening over and over. So playing small and it could be something really simple. It could be, and I love always a created things, you know, to sports because sports is a really good analogy for life. So you know, I grew up playing tennis. I played tennis small, meaning that I didn’t really push myself, you know, college and afterwards, because I am a really good athlete. And I’m not bragging and saying that my whole family is. My grandfather was, you know, like a scratch golfer when they had wooden clubs. My dad’s an excellent golfer. So is my mom. My brother’s a fabulous golfer. We’re all great tennis players. And I think that if I had really pushed harder, like really pushed and stuck with it and wasn’t like, wanna live this New York City lifestyle and get this cool job and like, you know, go to all the celebrity parties and the fashion shows and these are all the things I ended up doing. I would have really stuck with it. So unfortunately, I can admit it, I played tennis small. I wish I played it bigger because it’s just such a fabulous sport. just can’t, you know, I love it, and the season runs year round, which is amazing. So really just challenge yourself as much as you can and don’t live in fear because if you live in fear, you’re always gonna play small. It’s okay to fail and rejection’s a great part of life. We are constantly getting rejected. I don’t care who you are, except for Brad Pitt, he never gets rejected, but I don’t care who it is. It could be the smallest of things.
It could be you’re online and someone cuts to you at the Starbucks and you’re like, excuse me. And they’re like, who do you think you are? I’m just here picking up my to go drink, like move out of my way. That’s a slight form of rejection, right? It’s like this person thinks they’re better than me. It’s okay. We need it. It’s part of our life and it’s really good for our egos.
Recognizing Regret: The Cost of Playing Small
Dagmar (06:49): What were some situations in your life where you played small
Chloe (06:56): Well, I just mentioned the tennis, which is, you know, a big thing. I wish that I had really pushed that more. Another thing was, and I still think about it today, and this is like literally 20 years ago, where I was working in my father’s commercial real estate company, as you know, the family business, which really helped me become an incredible businesswoman and master negotiator. So I don’t regret any of that, but
At the time, it was just something maybe I was gonna do for a little while. You know, I’d grown up in the business and I was sending letters out to all the big magazines, to Glamour, to Vogue. And I really wanted to work in a magazine. And this is in my very early 20s. I didn’t have a lot of experience then in terms of jobs, but I had a lot of business experience already because I’d started in my family’s business at 14 and I had already done, hi Kitty, some really large scale events already and I had interned at MTV. So I felt confident in that sense. So I had sent out all these resumes and I wrote directly to the editor in chief of all these. And my dad helped me and I put together these incredible cover letters. And this was over the summer when things were very slow. Cut to, and this is for everyone to listen to, the best time to try to get a new job is after the new year. Everyone resets, January 15th, February 1st is a great time. Come the new year, I get, because back then, physical letters, we were barely emailing then, I got a physical letter in the mail from Harper’s Bazaar, one of my top three choices, that they loved that I took initiative, I took the cover letter, and they wanted to interview me, and I was like, ecstatic.
And I saw the look on my dad’s face because I’d already been working with him and he just loved that I was working there and my brother was working there at the time. My ex-boyfriend was still working there, awkward. And I was like, I can’t do it. And I really started to enjoy the art of negotiating deals. And I never went on the interview. And I still wish to this day that I had at least gone because who knows what path I would have taken. So that was kind of a little small of me.
And it’s a bummer,
c’est la vie to life. is, you know, these are the things that we look back on. But had I gone on that interview, who knows? I could have been the editor-in-chief of another magazine at this point. And we’d be having another podcast.
Breaking Free from Passive Behavior: How to Show Up Fully
Dagmar (09:35): just adore you for you have a totally different life experience than I am. And I can see that because of your upbringing and how you were raised.
And I know it’s you can help other women with. When you’re raised as a, you’re the nice little girl. You please everybody. You serve everybody and really becomes your second skin.
I’m in situations in groups where I have knowledge of the topic, but I can see that they want to hold it shallow, they want to hold it light, they don’t want to go deep. That I’m playing it small consciously and not sharing what I know or my experience just to fit in. Another playing small, what I see when you’re in a group of new people.
And everybody is just checking each other out, right? That you don’t want to come across as a lecture or preaching. You know it all and hold yourself back. to stop doing it? Because it doesn’t feel good, right? If I’m doing it…
The Importance of Showing Up Fully in Every Situation
Chloe (10:43): or a nodal. Well, right. Well, it’s not natural. It’s not organic, right?
Our views of playing small, I’m seeing the things that we’re bringing up are different, right? I’m bringing up like life-changing moments that I wish I maybe had done a little bit differently. So small, but bigger picture, big. And you’re talking about really in everyday life, if you’re in a conversation with someone where there’s business, you’re at a dinner party and you don’t, my perception is, and this took me a long time.
No, I take that back. I was like this in my 20s, then I kind of my 30s did exactly who said it doesn’t feel contrary. Let me go into New York. So my cousin has this thing where he would say to me, so a Jap is a Jewish American princess. So he would say to me, if you want to meet the right guy when you go out, keep the Jap under wrap, right? Just kind of like flying to the radar and just be this cool, relaxed, laugh at all the jokes, you know, just… be as easy as possible in terms of a guy would say, ⁓ this is like, you know, she doesn’t have a big personality. She’s not super independent. so you wanted to be the opposite of everything I am. Okay. So I tried that for a while and I was like, chuck that away in the garbage can. So to answer your question is everyone should be exactly who they are and in every moment. Now read the room.
Knowing When to Step Forward and Speak Your Truth
If you’re somewhere where the energy is like, everyone’s kind of in this library chill zone vibe, you don’t come in guns blazing.
You know, Chloe’s here. You know, we don’t have to do all that. But I think that if a topic comes up or someone mentions something that you feel strongly about, if you do it in the right way and it’s delivered, you don’t have to deliver small. You can.
Dagmar (12:39): Give an example. How would you do it?
Chloe (12:42): Okay, well, I don’t wanna talk politics or religion, that would be good example for me, but I’m not gonna do that. I’ve been in situations where I’ve gone or an event and…
There’s not that many women, right? It’s like mostly men there or at a sporting event. And men don’t particularly think that women understand a lot about sports. I don’t know anything about football. So please don’t ask me. Most women don’t. There are some diehard women out there for the football fans. And when I say football, American football, not soccer. And I’ve been in situations where men just start talking and they’re talking about the scores and… there, because I’m thinking of something very particular when I was living in New York City. And they were going over basketball and you know, as a New Yorker, for anyone listening to this, or watching that the New York Knicks have not made it to the playoffs. And this deep into the playoffs is they just did this past year for like over 20 years. So once the the playoff season starts, if your team doesn’t make it in, you’re kind of done watching basketball. You have to pick other teams.
But that being said, there was a huge conversation about the family that owns the Knicks. They also own Madison Square Garden and the New York Rangers. And I worked for that family. And I did sign a very ironclad NDI, so I cannot get into too many details, but certain things were brought up. And then there was a public article about the owners, because this is public record, about the owners of the team that someone wrote in the New York Times, like a scathing post about how the owners should sell the team and why and how they’re not good for the franchise. So this topic came up and I’m sitting there like, because I know so much more information, I worked directly for this family and I’m sitting there biting my tongue and I’m like, I just have to say something because these people don’t know, they don’t have the facts and a lot of times we don’t. It’s stuff we read online, it’s someone that someone else tells us a family member, and I had a lot of knowledge on this subject. So I sat there and I finally just said, hey, listen, I can’t get into this, but I worked for this family and you guys are completely wrong and that is fake information and you have the stats incorrect. And they were like, holy, what, wait, what did you just say? You worked for who? What, what, what? And now all of a sudden I had their attention and I was like, that’s it, can’t say anything else, just gonna leave it at that.
But do your research, please. I would really implore you to do your research, and I left it at that. But I couldn’t hear it any longer. It was like an hour and a half in, and I finally had to say something.
Taking Action: Deliver Your Truth with Confidence
I didn’t say enough because I couldn’t, but I said something.
Dagmar (15:27): So what you’re saying is, if I’m in a situation where there’s a topic discussed, I’m very familiar with, a way how to deal with it, that you don’t play small, but don’t go out bold as to say, just to do more research and look at it from different perspectives.
Chloe (15:49): Also, it’s your delivery. I wanted to go in a little bit more assertive in what I wanted to say, and for obvious reasons I couldn’t, but also because it was a new setting. I’ve also had people, this has happened so many times over the years, I’d be at a bar, at a party, and I hear people talking about going on vacation. I’m not gonna go to Jamaica, it’s so dangerous, Jamaica’s so dangerous.
And I would get into these things with people and say, hi, I’m sorry, but I grew up in Jamaica and I have to hear why you’re saying that. Have you ever been? No. And I would get into these long dialogues with people and always have to like defend the island of Jamrock, but.
Do your research, make sure you have the correct information, but don’t be afraid to call people out if your delivery is correct and you’re doing it the right way. Don’t come in like I know it all, come in with the facts. Because if you come in with the facts, then people listen.
Dagmar (16:42): Makes total sense. It’s the same than online, right?
The Power of Taking Things Personally: Breaking Free from Negativity
Don’t start, if you don’t want to play small and want to share your opinion, your thoughts, whatever, come with the facts, not just with feelings.
Chloe (16:58): Absolutely, take the feeling out of it. Just like you would say to me when we worked together in a previous job, take the emotion out. If more people did that in general, that’s one of the five things in the power of Kabbalah that is taught constantly. Don’t take anything personal and it’s a very hard thing to do. But someone could come up to you on the street or they could brush up to you. This happens all the time in my neighborhood, you know, with the dogs and the cars are coming or people are screaming in the street, move or get out of the way or, you know, someone said the other day, get your furry, ugly dog out of the way. And I was like, then I was like, wait, I don’t care. He’s the best looking dog in this neighborhood. He can win a contest. And like two seconds later, I was like, bye. It didn’t even affect me. You really, you just can’t take things personally. You to not let things bother you. And if you can do that, you’ll start playing bigger and not smaller.
Conclusion: Taking Control and Breaking Free from Smallness
Dagmar (17:57): Let’s take this as the takeaway for today before we end the episode. The playing small has really many different nuances. sometimes it comes from conscious decisions. A lot of times comes from subconscious decisions. Triggered by childhood, the environment you’re in. And when you’re in it, and you want to stop playing small. Do exactly what Chloe said that prepare yourself consciously how you want to portray yourself and then share the facts not in an emotional way but more in neutral way so that you’re seen and heard and you don’t start a huge two-hour discussion you cannot get out of it.
Chloe (18:51): And we’ve all been in those and they go nowhere. They go around in a circle.
Dagmar (18:54): Right, they go nowhere before I invite everybody to connect with you, if they want to gain more clarity or breakthrough, they are just tired of stop playing small, what is the one message you would give somebody who’s tired of playing small but doesn’t know what to do next or where to start?
Chloe (19:15): Well, the first portion of that answer is contact me, because I’ll help you. That’s number one. I mean, you just left that wide open for me. Thank you, Dagmar. I’ll give you a little sprinkle, a little crumb. And then if you’re seriously interested, ladies and gents, is that you have to believe in yourself first and foremost. And I know I’ve said this previously, but this answer goes to a lot of questions. If you have your mantras every day that you tell yourself and you believe in who you are and you know that you can be bigger and do better and hit your true potential, then you’ll have the breakthrough. But you have to break that cycle and take the negative energy and the vibrations out of your body and chuck them all the way in the Pacific ocean, not even the Atlantic. Well, we’re on the side of Atlantic. Throw them in the Mediterranean Sea and the Caribbean, wherever you want. But you have to release that because if you don’t, then you’re going to continue to play small and I don’t want anyone to play small.
Dagmar (20:20): That’s very insightful, especially when I think about what you teach me all the time. What’s my big goal, right? What is the, what’s my purpose and what do I want to accomplish and reach? And do I want to hold onto negativity and focus on what I don’t want? Or do I want to focus on what I want? for that, let’s end the episode with this, that key factor to many many topics Chloe and I discussed is to also explore what you want in life and to figure this out we will need another episode thank you so much.
Chloe (21:03): Look at you with the little cliffhanger there. Like to be continued, dot, dot, dot. I like it.
Dagmar (21:09): just want to hold them short. Why episodes so they can be easily digest and action steps taken, not just hurt, not just thought through, but That’s the key of changing and the key of rewiring your brain and creating a new mindset.
Chloe (21:17): Absolutely.
Absolutely.
Dagmar (21:32): So thank you so much everybody for listening today and thank you so much Chloe for always sharing your wisdom and your boldness the way how you portray life, which is beautiful.
Chloe (21:45): Me bold, never.
Dagmar (21:46): Don’t forget to subscribe everybody on your Tuesdays. Yeah.
Chloe (21:46): Only, only on Tuesdays.
Today’s Tuesday, right? Thank you everyone at Problem Solve Her on Instagram, problemsolveher.com, no E and solve, it’s playing words. Apple Podcasts and Spotify and YouTube. ⁓
Dagmar (22:01): Yeah, subscribe. Thank you.
Chloe (22:04): We love you, we hear you, we see you.
